Close Menu
Best in TechnologyBest in Technology
  • News
  • Phones
  • Laptops
  • Gadgets
  • Gaming
  • AI
  • Tips
  • More
    • Web Stories
    • Global
    • Press Release

Subscribe to Updates

Get the latest tech news and updates directly to your inbox.

What's On

Elon Musk Unveils Grok 4 Amid Controversy Over Chatbot’s Antisemitic Posts

10 July 2025

iPhone 17 Air Colour Options Hinted in New Leak; Could Launch in Four Shades

10 July 2025

McDonald’s AI Hiring Bot Exposed Millions of Applicants’ Data to Hackers Who Tried the Password ‘123456’

10 July 2025
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
Just In
  • Elon Musk Unveils Grok 4 Amid Controversy Over Chatbot’s Antisemitic Posts
  • iPhone 17 Air Colour Options Hinted in New Leak; Could Launch in Four Shades
  • McDonald’s AI Hiring Bot Exposed Millions of Applicants’ Data to Hackers Who Tried the Password ‘123456’
  • Samsung Galaxy Watch 8 (44mm) Online at Lowest Price in India
  • Our Favorite TV for Most People Is at Its Lowest Price Ever on Prime Day
  • Tecno Pova 7 5G, Pova 7 Pro 5G With Dimensity 7300 Ultimate SoC Sale in India Starts Today: Price, Offers
  • The ‘Click-to-Cancel’ Rule Was Killed, but Consumer Advocates Could Revive It
  • The Peloton Tread, Bike, and Row Are On Sale for Amazon Prime Day
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram Pinterest Vimeo
Best in TechnologyBest in Technology
  • News
  • Phones
  • Laptops
  • Gadgets
  • Gaming
  • AI
  • Tips
  • More
    • Web Stories
    • Global
    • Press Release
Subscribe
Best in TechnologyBest in Technology
Home » This Website Tracked Hate Crimes in India. Then the Government Took It Offline
News

This Website Tracked Hate Crimes in India. Then the Government Took It Offline

News RoomBy News Room12 February 20243 Mins Read
Share Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Reddit Telegram Email
Share
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email

Hindutva Watch, with its more than 79,000 followers on X, and its near daily documentation of riots, violence, and instances of BJP politicians spouting anti-Muslim rhetoric does little to bolster the party’s image. The instances documented by Hindutva Watch also run counter to the image of a US ally committed to “freedom, democracy, human rights, inclusion, pluralism, and equal opportunities for all citizens,” as a joint statement released during Modi’s US visit in June 2023 proclaimed.

And Chima says that right now, before the official campaign season in India kicks off, is a critical moment for controlling the information ecosystem. Once the elections begin in earnest, it will be more difficult for government officials working for the executive branch to issue blocking orders without possibly violating the country’s electoral code.

“We are worried about the signal they’re trying to send to tech platforms, that these are people who the government does not want to have on the web,” he says.“From now until the end of February, it is the one moment when the government will be sending as many messages as it can using these sorts of tools.”

Mishi Choudhary, a lawyer and general counsel at Virtu and former legal director at the Software Freedom Law Center, says that the laws around these blocking orders are particularly insidious because the government is not required to explain what about a website, account, or piece of content is dangerous or violative, making it difficult for platforms, ISPs, or users to push back.

“They’re left in the dark to figure out what’s really happening,” she says. And though they’re meant to be issued through the courts, websites or users who are blocked are “never given a hearing.”

“The orders are completely issued by executive branch officials. There’s no independent checks,” says Chima. “It’s civil servants who decide whether the orders should be executed and its civil servants who later stand in review of their own orders. You can’t even get copies of the data on orders themselves, on blocking orders because the government asserts that they’re confidential.”

And for platforms, resisting these takedown orders can be fraught, if not impossible, especially in such a populace country–India is X’s third largest market, with some 30 million users. In 2021, when thousands of farmers protested new agriculture laws, MeitY issued hundreds of blocking orders to X, then Twitter. The platform challenged several of the orders in court, arguing that many of the blocking orders failed to meet the government’s own standards for removal. But in July 2023, the case was dismissed, and a $61,000 fine was levied against the company for not executing the takedowns fast enough.

India also has what many experts refer to as “hostage taking laws,” which require platforms to appoint a legal representative in-country who can be held responsible, or even arrested, if a platform does not comply with government orders. After Elon Musk took over X in October 2022, he laid off a vast majority of the policy and trust and safety staff that would normally interface with civil society groups like Hindutva Watch or Access Now to alert them of blocking orders, making it even harder to discern what’s actually happening.

Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
Previous ArticleSamsung Galaxy Book 4 Series Pre-Reservations Begin Ahead of Launch in India
Next Article 5 best Super Bowl 2024 movie & TV trailers, ranked

Related Articles

News

Elon Musk Unveils Grok 4 Amid Controversy Over Chatbot’s Antisemitic Posts

10 July 2025
News

McDonald’s AI Hiring Bot Exposed Millions of Applicants’ Data to Hackers Who Tried the Password ‘123456’

10 July 2025
News

Our Favorite TV for Most People Is at Its Lowest Price Ever on Prime Day

10 July 2025
News

The ‘Click-to-Cancel’ Rule Was Killed, but Consumer Advocates Could Revive It

10 July 2025
News

The Peloton Tread, Bike, and Row Are On Sale for Amazon Prime Day

10 July 2025
News

The Best Dyson Prime Day Deals on Vacuums, Fans, and Hair Tools

10 July 2025
Demo
Top Articles

ChatGPT o1 vs. o1-mini vs. 4o: Which should you use?

15 December 2024101 Views

Costco partners with Electric Era to bring back EV charging in the U.S.

28 October 202495 Views

Oppo Reno 14, Reno 14 Pro India Launch Timeline and Colourways Leaked

27 May 202582 Views

Subscribe to Updates

Get the latest tech news and updates directly to your inbox.

Latest News
Phones

Tecno Pova 7 5G, Pova 7 Pro 5G With Dimensity 7300 Ultimate SoC Sale in India Starts Today: Price, Offers

News Room10 July 2025
News

The ‘Click-to-Cancel’ Rule Was Killed, but Consumer Advocates Could Revive It

News Room10 July 2025
News

The Peloton Tread, Bike, and Row Are On Sale for Amazon Prime Day

News Room10 July 2025
Most Popular

The Spectacular Burnout of a Solar Panel Salesman

13 January 2025124 Views

ChatGPT o1 vs. o1-mini vs. 4o: Which should you use?

15 December 2024101 Views

Costco partners with Electric Era to bring back EV charging in the U.S.

28 October 202495 Views
Our Picks

Samsung Galaxy Watch 8 (44mm) Online at Lowest Price in India

10 July 2025

Our Favorite TV for Most People Is at Its Lowest Price Ever on Prime Day

10 July 2025

Tecno Pova 7 5G, Pova 7 Pro 5G With Dimensity 7300 Ultimate SoC Sale in India Starts Today: Price, Offers

10 July 2025

Subscribe to Updates

Get the latest tech news and updates directly to your inbox.

Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram Pinterest
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of use
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
© 2025 Best in Technology. All Rights Reserved.

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.