Close Menu
Best in TechnologyBest in Technology
  • News
  • Phones
  • Laptops
  • Gadgets
  • Gaming
  • AI
  • Tips
  • More
    • Web Stories
    • Global
    • Press Release

Subscribe to Updates

Get the latest tech news and updates directly to your inbox.

What's On

This Acer Chromebook is on sale for a very affordable $149

10 May 2025

Do You Really Have to Stop Using Windows 10?

10 May 2025

Panasonic’s flagship 65-inch OLED has a $700 discount today

10 May 2025
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
Just In
  • This Acer Chromebook is on sale for a very affordable $149
  • Do You Really Have to Stop Using Windows 10?
  • Panasonic’s flagship 65-inch OLED has a $700 discount today
  • Sonos CEO: ‘We All Feel Really Terrible’ About the Bungled App Update
  • Tom Cruise is human. Here’s the one stunt he couldn’t do in Mission: Impossible
  • Review: Thule Chariot Cross 2 Bike Trailer and Stroller
  • The Backbone Pro Is A Decent Upgrade To Arguably The Best Mobile Controller
  • LG’s best OLED TV of 2024 is on sale for $1,000 off today
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram Pinterest Vimeo
Best in TechnologyBest in Technology
  • News
  • Phones
  • Laptops
  • Gadgets
  • Gaming
  • AI
  • Tips
  • More
    • Web Stories
    • Global
    • Press Release
Subscribe
Best in TechnologyBest in Technology
Home » The Internet Archive Loses Its Appeal of a Major Copyright Case
News

The Internet Archive Loses Its Appeal of a Major Copyright Case

News RoomBy News Room4 September 20243 Mins Read
Share Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Reddit Telegram Email
Share
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email

The Internet Archive has lost a major legal battle—in a decision that could have a significant impact on the future of internet history. Today, the US Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit ruled against the long-running digital archive, upholding an earlier ruling in Hachette v. Internet Archive that found that one of the Internet Archive’s book digitization projects violated copyright law.

Notably, the appeals court’s ruling rejects the Internet Archive’s argument that its lending practices were shielded by the fair use doctrine, which permits for copyright infringement in certain circumstances, calling it “unpersuasive.”

In March 2020, the Internet Archive, a San Francisco-based nonprofit, launched a program called the National Emergency Library, or NEL. Library closures caused by the pandemic had left students, researchers, and readers unable to access millions of books, and the Internet Archive has said it was responding to calls from regular people and other librarians to help those at home get access to the books they needed.

The NEL was an offshoot of an ongoing digital lending project called the Open Library, in which the Internet Archive scans physical copies of library books and lets people check out the digital copies as though they’re regular reading material instead of ebooks. The Open Library lent the books to one person at a time—but the NEL removed this ratio rule, instead letting large numbers of people borrow each scanned book at once.

The NEL was the subject of backlash soon after its launch, with some authors arguing that it was tantamount to piracy. In response, the Internet Archive within two months scuttled its emergency approach and reinstated the lending caps. But the damage was done. In June 2020, major publishing houses, including Hachette, HarperCollins, Penguin Random House, and Wiley, filed the lawsuit.

In March 2023, the district court ruled in favor of the publishers. Judge John G. Koeltl found that the Internet Archive had created “derivative works,” arguing that there was “nothing transformative” about its copying and lending. After the initial ruling in Hachette v. Internet Archive, the parties agreed upon settlement terms—the details of which have not been disclosed—though the archive still filed an appeal.

James Grimmelmann, a professor of digital and internet law at Cornell University, says the verdict is “not terribly surprising” in the context of how courts have recently interpreted fair use.

The Internet Archive did eke out a Pyrrhic victory in the appeal. Although the Second Circuit sided with the district court’s initial ruling, it clarified that it did not view the Internet Archive as a commercial entity, instead emphasizing that it was clearly a nonprofit operation. Grimmelmann sees this as the right call: “I’m glad to see that the Second Circuit fixed that mistake.” (He signed an amicus brief in the appeal arguing that it was wrong to classify the use as commercial.)

“We are disappointed in today’s opinion about the Internet Archive’s digital lending of books that are available electronically elsewhere. We are reviewing the court’s opinion and will continue to defend the rights of libraries to own, lend, and preserve books,” Internet Archive director of library services Chris Freeland tells WIRED.

Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
Previous ArticleAfter its studio criticized Microsoft, Enotria: The Last Song is coming to Xbox
Next Article Warhammer 40,000: Space Marine 2 ending explained

Related Articles

News

This Acer Chromebook is on sale for a very affordable $149

10 May 2025
News

Do You Really Have to Stop Using Windows 10?

10 May 2025
News

Panasonic’s flagship 65-inch OLED has a $700 discount today

10 May 2025
News

Sonos CEO: ‘We All Feel Really Terrible’ About the Bungled App Update

9 May 2025
News

Tom Cruise is human. Here’s the one stunt he couldn’t do in Mission: Impossible

9 May 2025
News

Review: Thule Chariot Cross 2 Bike Trailer and Stroller

9 May 2025
Demo
Top Articles

Costco partners with Electric Era to bring back EV charging in the U.S.

28 October 202493 Views

ChatGPT o1 vs. o1-mini vs. 4o: Which should you use?

15 December 202482 Views

5 laptops to buy instead of the M4 MacBook Pro

17 November 202457 Views

Subscribe to Updates

Get the latest tech news and updates directly to your inbox.

Latest News
News

Review: Thule Chariot Cross 2 Bike Trailer and Stroller

News Room9 May 2025
Gaming

The Backbone Pro Is A Decent Upgrade To Arguably The Best Mobile Controller

News Room9 May 2025
News

LG’s best OLED TV of 2024 is on sale for $1,000 off today

News Room9 May 2025
Most Popular

The Spectacular Burnout of a Solar Panel Salesman

13 January 2025118 Views

Costco partners with Electric Era to bring back EV charging in the U.S.

28 October 202493 Views

ChatGPT o1 vs. o1-mini vs. 4o: Which should you use?

15 December 202482 Views
Our Picks

Sonos CEO: ‘We All Feel Really Terrible’ About the Bungled App Update

9 May 2025

Tom Cruise is human. Here’s the one stunt he couldn’t do in Mission: Impossible

9 May 2025

Review: Thule Chariot Cross 2 Bike Trailer and Stroller

9 May 2025

Subscribe to Updates

Get the latest tech news and updates directly to your inbox.

Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram Pinterest
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of use
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
© 2025 Best in Technology. All Rights Reserved.

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.